Typefully

China Eastern Airlines Flight MU5735 - FOIA Review

Avatar

Share

 • 

16 days ago

 • 

View on X

1/10 I just spent the last few hours checking the FOIA data for the Boeing 737-800 crash of Mar 21, 2022. The data is available on NTSB website (docket DCA22WA102). Got some quick processing and analysis done with Sonnet 4.6 and DeepSeekV4 flash. @CharlesBremner @NTSB @ByChunHan
2/10 Here is the GitHub repo. Feel free to fork, to blame, etc. I just did some PDF review and some quick data analysis. github.com/nemonominem/NTSB_FOIA_DCA22WA102/tree/main
3/10 There are some interesting aspects to this story. For instance I can't make any sense of the fact that apparently the US did not keep some copy of the CVR (Cockpit Voice Recording), given all the pain they took to recover it and copies they would have needed. @Kubota_Yoko
4/10 Also, note that apparently, the FOIA was filed by a Chinese citizen! Well done. There is some interesting discussion 1 day before the 2Y limit after which the NTSB has an obligation to answer FOIA, even if China has not release its report, whatever China wanted. @alyrose
5/10 I also quickly produced compressed OCR versions of the FOAI PDFs.
6/10 Another extract of analysis.md
7/10 Note that they are data quirks that require some cleaning when displaying. @AndrewTangel Check the data using the GitHub Page: nemonominem.github.io/NTSB_FOIA_DCA22WA102/EDA_1.html
8/10 Context: x.com/Byron_Wan/status/2051333127717708097?s=20 Four years later, China still has not released its official report. But remember: disclosure may endanger national security and social stability. The pattern should be familiar by now.
9/10 Here is the key analysis file I produced, with Claude Sonnet 4.6. github.com/nemonominem/NTSB_FOIA_DCA22WA102/blob/main/analysis.md Repo address: github.com/nemonominem/NTSB_FOIA_DCA22WA102/
Avatar

Gilles Demaneuf

@gdemaneuf

Pointy Head. Opinions, analyses and views expressed are purely mine and should not in any way be characterised as representing any institution or company.